Everyone Will Be Happy
Michelle greeted her with a bright smile, and Ian, standing beside her, stared with his eyes wide open.
Under the weight of those two completely different reactions, Anna lowered her head.
"Oh, hello…."
"Mm-hmm. If you'd arrived a little earlier, we could've eaten dinner together. What a shame."
"I was going to eat with my sister…."
"Oh, right. Come in, come in."
At Michelle’s invitation, Anna went inside and sat on the living room sofa, but Ian still wore a bewildered expression.
He looked as though he wanted to hear the whole story right away, but Anna only averted her eyes in silence.
"Huh? The school called? Why don't you two talk for a moment?"
As soon as Michelle disappeared into the room, Ian leaned toward Anna and asked in a low voice, as if he’d been waiting for the chance.
"What’s going on? Were you invited too, Anna?"
"U-um…."
Ian’s brows knotted with worry.
Of course he’d be confused. Michelle had invited another woman to a date with her lover—moreover, a woman he was secretly seeing on the side.
"What did Michelle want?"
"Well…."
Anna trailed off, unable to answer clearly.
The root of this situation lay in the meeting held at her house last Saturday.
“If you’d be willing to love both of us equally… I think I could accept that.”
That was Anna’s answer to Michelle’s question.
After hearing it, Michelle had revealed that she was dating Ian and said she would help make Anna’s feelings come true too.
In other words, she wanted the two of them to happily become Ian’s lovers together.
Anna already knew, from Ian himself, that Michelle was surprisingly tolerant of his double life.
Still, she had never imagined Michelle would actually try to add another woman to her boyfriend’s harem, so Anna couldn’t help being shocked.
And yet, in another sense, she had felt relieved too.
Because their feelings were aligned enough that no one had to get hurt.
Besides, for Anna—who lacked confidence and couldn’t bring herself to approach Ian on her own—Michelle was practically the strongest ally she could have hoped for.
That was why Anna had accepted Michelle’s invitation.
"Mm?"
Ian prompted her again, urging her to go on.
But there was no way Anna could answer smoothly.
To say that Michelle had invited them here to bring the two of them together….
"I-I don’t really know…. The teacher just called for me…."
Afraid that her lie might be exposed, she mumbled while avoiding his eyes.
It was the kind of evasive behavior that would have seemed suspicious to anyone, but Anna was shy like this so often that Ian didn’t suspect a thing.
"Sorry, you two."
When Michelle returned from the room and sat down on the sofa between them, an awkward silence settled for a brief moment.
It was Michelle who broke it first.
"Ian."
"Yeah?"
"Anna says she likes you."
"Cough, what?"
Ian sputtered, practically choking on his own breath as he stared at her.
Even if he hadn’t said anything aloud, Anna had been just as shocked.
She had expected Michelle to back her up, but she hadn’t expected her to be so direct about it.
"Teacher…."
"Don’t worry, Anna. Leave it to your teacher. Ian!"
"W-what…?"
"You promised you'd grant me one wish, remember?"
"I did…?"
What Michelle said next was enough to leave both students stunned.
"Go out with Anna!"
---
My eyes were probably as big as five-hundred-won coins right now.
Who would’ve guessed Michelle would say something like that?
"What do you mean… are you serious?"
"Yes."
There wasn’t the slightest hesitation in her answer.
I knew she was broad-minded, but to think she’d actively try to make me juggle two relationships at once.
I glanced sideways at Anna.
She looked just as shocked, so it seemed she’d come here without knowing Michelle’s intentions either.
…But would Michelle really have acted without considering Anna’s opinion, if not mine?
Her? So full of consideration for other people, especially her students?
"Actually, I talked with Anna this past weekend. That’s when I found out she liked you, Ian. But she said she didn’t have the courage to tell you how she felt."
Her face suddenly turned solemn, and she clenched a fist as she went on.
"That’s when I thought, why don’t we all be happy together? So I decided to tell you we’re dating, and help Anna confess her feelings."
At last, I was beginning to understand the situation.
She’d decided to help Anna, who lacked the confidence to come closer to me.
And yet, no matter how I looked at it, it was still astonishing.
When I confessed to her in the beginning, she had turned me down on the grounds of school rules and a teacher’s responsibility. Now she was the one pushing me to date someone else.
I was happy to think my feelings for her had changed her, but the result was this bewildering mess, and that left me feeling complicated.
Still, if Anna had come here knowing all this, why was she reacting so shocked?
Had she not expected Michelle to go this far, this quickly?
I forced myself to calm down and sort through my thoughts.
Michelle was trying to bring Anna and me together.
From the sound of it, she didn’t seem to know that Anna and I were already involved.
Honestly, dating Anna was something I’d wanted for a long time.
The problem was that our relationship was far more intimate than Michelle realized.
…Maybe I should just tell her everything now.
If Michelle got angry, I’d apologize sincerely.
I’d already prepared myself for that the moment I confessed to Anna.
Having made up my mind, I was just about to speak when—
"…."
I couldn’t get the words out.
It wasn’t because of anything else; Michelle simply looked too happy.
"Since Anna and I both like you, Ian, all you have to do is like us both equally! Then everyone will be happy."
She’d said something similar before—that she wanted to be close to the people who liked me, almost like a fan club.
Maybe because her wish was on the verge of coming true, she looked more excited than I’d ever seen her. And if I poured cold water on it now by confessing the truth, the moment would be ruined, which made it harder and harder to speak.
…Anna seemed to be thinking along the same lines as me.
She’d been carrying on this affair with me while also feeling guilty toward Michelle, just as I did.
She probably knew she should tell the truth, but from her position, saying it first wouldn’t be easy.
For now, I’d let Michelle have this, and when the time was right, I’d be honest.
"Ian."
Lost in thought, I flinched when I heard my name.
"Huh?"
"You said Anna was a good girl earlier, right?"
"I did…?"
"Oh my goodness, Anna! That’s wonderful. Congratulations!"
Anyone watching would have thought they were already dating.
"Now, why don’t you sit here?"
Under Michelle’s guidance, Anna and I ended up sitting face-to-face on the sofa.
Michelle took both our hands and said, "Anna, you didn’t have the courage to say it until now, but this time you’re going to be honest about how you feel. Ian said he likes you too, so don’t be afraid to show it!"
I hadn’t actually said anything that direct, but I didn’t bother correcting her and just stayed quiet to match the mood.
"…."
"Come on, Anna. You can do it!"
Michelle cheered on her hesitant student.
At her teacher’s voice, Anna finally opened her mouth cautiously.
"Ian…."
For some reason, it made my chest feel hot and awkward at the same time.
I waited in silence, and after a moment Anna spoke again.
"I’ve liked you for a long time…. A lot…."
"…."
"…And I want to keep liking you."
That was the end of Anna’s confession.
Looking at her blushing face and trembling lips, it seemed as though there was more she wanted to say, but this was apparently the limit of her courage.
"You did great, Anna. Now it’s Ian’s turn to answer."
"…."
"You can be honest. People’s hearts don’t always go the way they want. Anna, even if Ian turns you down, you don’t have to be too sad. You’re a good girl, so if you get to know each other slowly, I’m sure your feelings will reach him."
Michelle was as pushy as ever, yet it was also very much like her to think of both me and Anna at the same time.
She looked at me with a grave, focused gaze.
Anna, on the other hand, lowered the eyes that had been on me just moments before and waited for my answer.
Of course, my answer had already been decided.
The person who had always thought only of me, who had forgiven me for my huge mistakes simply because I was me.
There was only one thing I could say to Anna.
"I like you too, Anna."
"Mm…."
"Oh, thank goodness. Anna!"
Michelle hugged Anna and shook her from side to side.
Talking so seriously about it made me feel embarrassed and self-conscious, but seeing how delighted Michelle was, I started wondering if I was the weird one.
"Come on, you two, hold hands!"
Michelle tugged my hand and Anna’s together, then clapped her hands with delight.
I felt like a kindergartener being reconciled with a friend thanks to the teacher’s help, but it didn’t bother me.
Because of Michelle, Anna had found the courage to speak up, and we’d become even closer, just as we’d both wanted.
"This is so great. I’m really glad…."
Michelle’s face filled with emotion as she pulled Anna to her feet.
"Anna, it’s time for the next step. Let’s go!"
"Huh?"
Michelle whisked the dazed Anna away to her room in an instant.
"Haaah…."
As the commotion finally died down, a long sigh escaped me on its own.
When I’d come here, I’d never imagined this kind of situation would unfold.
But when was I supposed to tell the truth?
Just as I was agonizing over it, a voice came from beyond Michelle’s bedroom door.
"Ian! Could you come here for a second?!"
Curious, I opened the door and went inside—and froze in place.
The two women, who had been dressed normally just moments ago, were now wearing outfits that left little to the imagination.
The first person to catch my eye was Anna.
She was wearing a string bra and string panties that exposed most of her skin.
Bits of fur-like cloth, suggestive of an animal, were barely covering her nipples and sex.
On her head was a pair of puppy ears, and judging by the fur color matching the material covering her nipples and sex, it seemed to be a sexy lingerie set themed around a dog.
If Anna was the dog, then Michelle was the pig.
A pink fishnet outfit clung to every inch of her body.
Her breasts and thighs were pressed and outlined in a way that made her look indecently alluring, and there were even round openings cut around her areolas and sex.
On top of that, she wore pig ears on her head.
It was the sow outfit she’d worn when we’d filmed that sex video together.
"Wh-what is this…?"
At my flustered reaction, Michelle laughed and answered, "You know, I asked Anna about this the other day. I asked what she wanted to be called if she dated you. And she said she wanted to be called a puppy. Isn’t Anna just too cute?"
No, Michelle. She probably meant bitch, but couldn’t bring herself to say it in front of you.
I swallowed the words that rose to my throat, along with a mouthful of saliva.
With two beauties dressed like this in front of me, it was hard to look away.
"I guess so. She’s cute…. But why are you wearing outfits like this all of a sudden?"
"Anna said she wanted to do naughty things with Ian!"
That might have been what Anna said, but Michelle’s own outfit looked just as eager to get to work.
So that was why she’d asked if I could do twice as much today.
"Ah… during last week’s meeting?"
"Nope. At the beginning of the semester, Anna came to the faculty office and asked for counseling."
So she meant back when I’d used Charm Magic to keep Anna from finding out.
The look Michelle gave me seemed to say, You heard it too back then.
"T-teacher…."
Anna called to Michelle in distress, twisting her body awkwardly while covering her most important parts with her hands.
She hadn’t expected to end up wearing something like this either.
"Come on, you two. Come here. We’ll fulfill Anna’s wish, and if you do something naughty together, you’ll get even closer. Ian, take your clothes off."
In no time at all, I was naked, and Michelle led me by the hand so that I was facing Anna again, this time on the bed instead of the sofa.
For some reason, we were both sitting politely on our knees.
"Since Ian has experience, I want you to take the lead gently. And don’t forget to make Anna feel safe, okay?"
Her bulldozer-like decisiveness really did remind me of some secretary from somewhere.
Even though I was still reeling, my cock was slowly starting to stir regardless.
Anna was looking at me shyly in that obscene outfit that could only be described as puppy-like in the crudest sense, and there was no way I could stay unaffected.
And beyond that, unlike the master-and-bitch relationship we’d had until now, the idea of having sex with Anna like a normal couple made my heart pound.
"Anna…."
I reached a hand toward the back of her head as she waited, tense and nervous.
Then I slowly drew her toward me, and at the same time leaned in myself, letting our lips meet.
"Hahup, huhp… chu."
Kissing Anna had always happened in the middle of wild sex, so doing it so quietly felt strangely fresh.
Maybe that was why her scent and the taste of her saliva seemed even more intense than usual.
I moved my tongue busily and sent my hand up toward her chest.
After lifting the string bra that barely covered her nipples, I kneaded her breast with my whole palm.
"Mmnh, hiiit! Hahup, churop…."
Anna kept kissing me even as she let out soft, breathy sounds at my touch.
As if returning the favor for my caresses, she began to slowly stroke my hardened cock with her hand.
Her gentle fingers wrapped around my shaft, and precum kept spilling out. Anna spread it over the length of me and gradually quickened her strokes.
"Anna, that feels good."
"Sluup, hup…."
Anna didn’t answer, too absorbed in kissing me and jerking me off.
Every now and then she’d pull back and look at me with that same girlishly shy expression, yet the way she handled my cock was downright practiced.
Of course it was. She’d had sex with me plenty of times by now.
Tap, tap, tap, tap.
Once a fair amount of fluid began seeping from my urethra, her hand movements took on a rhythmic pace.
She gripped and worked me with just the right amount of pressure—not too weak, not too rough—and my pleasure kept building steadily.
Wanting to make Anna feel even better too, I kept kissing her while carefully massaging her breasts.
"Sluup, chu… Ian…. Hahup."
When our lips finally parted after a long while, a clear thread of saliva stretched between Anna and me.
She kept jerking me off while staring at me, and I let myself savor the feeling of her fingers while my eyes were helplessly drawn to the shameless sight of her.
Tap, tap, tap, tap.
Her eyes were half-lidded and dazed, and her tongue peeked out slightly.
Every time she moved her arm, her round breasts swayed.
Just looking at her was enough to heighten the pleasure, and as my climax drew near, Anna seemed to sense it and quickened her hand even more.
Tap! Tap! Tap! Tap!
"Kh—Anna!"
Even as my brow crumpled, Anna never slowed down, only urging me closer to release.
My cock grew more and more sensitive, and just as the sensation of her hand catching on the ridge beneath the glans became especially intense, I shot my load.
After enjoying that brief burst of bliss, I looked at Anna—and saw that not a single drop of my semen had landed on her body.
It seemed she’d covered the head with her other hand just before I came.
Anna gazed deeply at the semen sticking to her hand.
She looked as though she might bring it to her mouth, but perhaps because Michelle was there, she didn’t.
Michelle, meanwhile, looked genuinely surprised.
"I was kind of shocked by how well Anna can handle a cock."
Then she wiped Anna’s hand and my cock clean with a tissue, brought out a condom, and handed it to me.
I’d brought one in anticipation of tonight too, but it looked like Michelle had prepared her own as well.
"Ian, hurry up and fulfill Anna’s wish!"
She was practically glowing with excitement, like she was watching a romance film or something.
At her command, I put on the condom and lay Anna down.
"Was it really your wish to do it with me?"
As I asked, pretending not to know, Anna blushed and nodded.
She had already slept with me so many times, and yet the way she still acted shy like this made the heat in my chest burn even more fiercely.
"Got it. I’ll do exactly as you want."