Lucy X Lumi (3)
Lee Ho-yeon had his own plan in mind. He would create a situation where Lucy had no choice but to refuse.
"F-Forcing it? Oh, y-yeah. M-Make your cock beg...."
Lucy's head spun from the flood of lewd words.
...How the hell do you even do that?
As her eyes darted away, Lucy spotted the bulge straining against Lee Ho-yeon's lower body.
"Th-that... uh...."
"What's wrong? You did it last time too. Spread your legs and beg me to shove my cock in."
"Spr-spread... c-cock...."
Lucy couldn't believe her ears. She never imagined things had progressed that far between Lumi and Lee Ho-yeon already. Her always-whiny little sister had grown up into a woman. A pang of inexplicable loneliness hit her.
And while Lucy was flustered, Lee Ho-yeon's hand slipped between her thighs. He wasn't planning an immediate thrust, but he needed to ramp up the pressure to force a confession out of her. His hand brushed her soft thigh, then reached the sticky slit.
"H-hng...!"
Did I go too far? Lee Ho-yeon wondered with a twinge of regret as he glanced at her face.
But contrary to his intent of drawing out the truth from her lips, Lucy slowly parted her legs. The gown fell away, exposing her smooth skin to the air. Her flushed face and the pink cleft gradually revealed between her thighs—it was a combination that could drive any man mad.
"P-please shove your cock in... Ho-yeon...."
Lee Ho-yeon approached her slowly, watching Lucy squeeze her eyes shut and whisper those filthy words in a shameful voice. In that moment, the reason that had been holding him back surrendered to lust. Even with his Clear Mind, sexual desire was the one urge he couldn't fully control. It bubbled up from deep inside him.
Thump. Thump.
What am I thinking? What the hell am I...!
At the same time, Lucy felt something strange stirring within her. The instant his hand touched her pussy, she couldn't resist—her legs just opened.
No. I can't give my first time like this.
Common sense tried to halt her body, but every movement of his hand conquered her too easily.
Tap. Tap.
Each light brush of his fingers against her pussy made Lucy feel like she was going insane. Suppressing the rising lust was impossible. She'd never felt anything like this, leaving her even more confused. Was it right to have her first experience disguised as Lumi? At this rate, her first time with the man she loved might be ruined.
Swish—
But this touch. This sensation. She couldn't refuse it. Caught in the irresistible bond of heroine and protagonist, Lucy faced a temptation she couldn't withstand.
"Ah, ahh...."
"I'm putting it in."
"Y-yes... Ho-yeon...."
In the end, Lee Ho-yeon's glans pressed against Lucy's pussy. A tingling spark jolted through her body—the irresistible starting point of pleasure. Just as his cock was about to slide into her pussy.
"Ah, n-no. No!"
Lucy finally shoved him away. At the very last second, she barely regained her senses and shook off the temptation. She knew that if she had sex in this state, they could never go back to their previous relationship.
But even as Lucy struggled, Lee Ho-yeon remained calmly still. Growing more desperate, she blurted out,
"I-I'm actually...!"
"I know. Lucy."
"...Huh?"
"I've known from the start. There's no way I wouldn't recognize you."
"Th-then why pretend not to know... Ngh, hnggg?!"
Lee Ho-yeon grabbed his cock and dragged it up along her pussy.
"That's what I wanted to say. Why did you come to me pretending to be Lumi?"
"...."
Lucy froze, caught off guard by his unexpected response.
*
A romantic scene where a naked man and woman gazed at each other. I was questioning Lucy.
"Lucy."
I met her eyes slowly.
"Y-yeah...."
"Be honest. Do you hate me?"
Things were unfolding exactly as I'd planned. Right before her confession could spill out, I'd preempt it by revealing I already knew. If I confessed first, she might get mad and turn it around on me—Why didn't you say something sooner? Even if she didn't blow up, it could still bruise our emotions a bit.
But not this time. Lucy was so shocked by my unforeseen reaction that she was getting drawn into my words.
"No. How could I...."
"Then you hate Lumi?"
"No! Absolutely not!"
"Then why? Why approach me by deceiving me as Lumi?"
Lucy looked at me, then cautiously opened her mouth.
"...I was afraid I'd be a burden to you two. I wanted to know your true feelings. I'm sorry. Really... I'm sorry. I keep doing things I have to apologize for... Sniff. I was scared you'd hate me...."
Lucy's eyes reddened. She'd been through a lot mentally. This was entirely my fault. I should have conquered her sooner, but other issues kept popping up, leaving her strategy half-done, always on the back burner.
If I couldn't seal the deal in a perfect setup like this, I wouldn't even qualify as a man.
"Lucy. You can just be honest with your feelings."
"...Is that really okay? Won't I be a burden?"
Her eyes trembled with anxiety.
"Yeah. I like you. It's a bit awkward saying it myself, but... I like both you and Lumi."
"You're trash... for real."
Heh. Finally, Lucy's face brightened a little. Even though I'd admitted in front of her that I liked another girl, she looked relieved, flashing a happy smile.
"Lee Ho-yeon."
"Yeah."
"I like you too. I've... always liked you. Since you saved me from Felix—no, maybe even before that.... I've always liked you. I was the one who liked you first... Sniff."
"Thanks. For telling me."
"Even if I'm second... I like you...."
"You're not second. You're both first."
I pulled the teary-eyed Lucy—tears like chicken shit plopping down—into my chest. Finally, one worry off my mind. I'd already confessed to Baek A-young like a total scumbag, and now I was doing the same to Lucy and Lumi. Regrettable, but unavoidable. A harem was trash by nature. Embracing that was the path of the harem king.
"Sniff... Hic...."
"It's okay. It's okay...."
I stroked her hair and held her close. Naturally, our bodies pressed together.
"But what's this down here?"
My cock naturally poked at her stomach.
"A physiological reaction...?"
"...You're such a trash."
It wasn't my fault. This body got aroused by a crying woman instead of pity or sympathy—that was the problem.
Lucy pulled slightly away from my embrace and placed her hand on my chest.
"...I like you. No, I love you."
"I love you too, Lucy. And Lumi."
Lucy averted her gaze shyly as she spoke.
"If it's you... it's okay. But it's my first time, so... be gentle."
"......Yeah. Of course."
Poke, poke—
Every lie stabbed at my conscience like a spinning awl. The tattered remnants of my moral compass were pricking away inside. Lucy still didn't know I'd already taken her first time.
But since my conscience was already ground to dust, I could endure this much pain. I couldn't hide it forever anyway. Bracing for the frontal assault, I slowly adjusted my position.
Squelch.
Normally, I'd start with a blowjob... but I felt guilty, and it wasn't the moment.
Gulp—
"Wh-why are you staring?"
Lucy was tensing her whole body, bracing for what was coming. I couldn't just thrust in like this.
"Your body's beautiful."
"Flattery won't get you anywhereee—!"
I suddenly grabbed her rigidly tense breasts. Her small frame let me maintain the pre-insertion position while fondling them.
"Haang, ah... Weird, it feels so weird...."
Rubbing and tweaking her perky pink nipples made Lucy twitch and moan. The texture was definitely similar to Lumi's—soft, plush, springy breasts. The way her face flushed shyly with every touch was cute, just like her sister's.
After fondling them a bit more, I slid my hand downward.
"Ng, ah, hng...."
Squelch—
My fingers delved into her slit.
This should be enough.
Pulling my fingers from her hole, sticky juices dripped down them. Brushing her clit with the slick digits made Lucy shudder and cling to my arm.
"Ahng, ah, hng. St-stop... Stop... It's getting weird. Hnggg...."
Squelch, squelch—
I rubbed her clit with my palm while fingering her hole. Loosening her up thoroughly so she wouldn't feel burdened when my cock went in.
"Hnggg... Khng... Hah."
I gently pried her arms off her ragged-breathing body and brought my glans to her entrance. Lucy, dazed from the paused touch, looked at me with foggy eyes before clamping her mouth shut and tensing up again. But she was much more relaxed than before, so insertion wouldn't be an issue.
"I'm putting it in, Lucy."
"Y-yeah. No, uh... They say the first time hurts. Be gentle...."
"Don't worry."
Squish—
I leaned in close and pushed my cock inside her. At that moment, Lucy lightly pushed back.
"Lucy?"
"Y-you have to make it beg too, right? I can't let only Lumi do it. I'll do it too."
"Uh, yeah...."
Calling her bluff now would just piss her off. Lucy slowly spread her legs, pulled her thighs apart with her hands, and spoke.
"Shove your cock in me too. G-gently, so it doesn't hurt."
"...Yeah."
Her embarrassed begging was adorable. We'd tangled bodies before with Lucy, but it wasn't proper sex—just a means to lift the aphrodisiac spell. I treated her like it was truly our first time.
"Hiiik... Hngp...."
Lucy scrunched her eyes and covered her mouth to stifle her moans. Even if it wasn't her real first, there'd still be some pain. Her muscles would be shocked after so long.
But it didn't hurt as much as she'd imagined—her half-lidded eyes cracked open.
"N-not a big deal. Ng. Doesn't hurt at all, hng...."
"Me too, fuu. Feels good."
I endured the tight squeeze gripping me from all sides and pushed my glans deeper.
"Hng, ahngp... Sl-slowly... Hn...."
I moved my hips slowly as she asked. Her small frame might find my size overwhelming. With Lumi, an artifact had dulled the pain during her first time.
Feeling the wriggling walls, I sheathed myself fully. Lucy, eyes squeezed shut, spoke up.
"Haa, haa... All the way in?"
"Yeah. To the hilt."
"N-not as bad as I thought. ...D-did a lot of blood come out? They say the sheets get soaked...."
"Uh... Yeah. It's fine."
Instead of answering her weird info, I started moving my hips slowly.
"Haht, ahng.... W-wait. Ahng...."
Thump, thump—
Her breasts jiggled with every thrust.
"W-wait. Why no blood?"
I'd tried to angle away from her view, but she spotted the clean sheets anyway.
"...Not everyone bleeds their first time. Some people don't."
Lucy panicked at the pristine bed, but I hugged her tight and averted my eyes. I could play it off as no big deal. But... my conscience stung too much. The shredded triangle was thrashing wildly inside me.
Noticing my gaze shift, Lucy grew anxious and poured out words.
"N-no, really. It is my first time. Please believe me."
Tears welled in her eyes. How wronged did she feel to cry like this? Startled, I soothed her.
"Calm down, Lucy. I believe you. Maybe it tore from exercise or something... I don't doubt you at all, so don't worry."
"It's my first. Completely first. My first man's body. Hng... First cock in my pussy... Ahng, but why does it feel so gooood...!"
Squelch— Squelch—
A cock really was the best remedy. Lucy went from indignant to trembling and impaling herself on me with my thrusts.